February 4, 2005 - Friday Eucharist, Diocese of Georgia Convention
Matthew 5:1-12

Sermon by The Rev. Steph Brett, Assistant Rector, Good Shepherd, Augusta

In my middle school there was a pretty clear standard.

It’s hard to say how these things get defined. It’s hard to say how they’re established. But standards do get defined, clearly defined. And every boy is clear about them.

To be someone at East Naples Middle School you had to measure up to the standard, or at least come pretty close. And your measurement then determined your status among the boys. I know it sounds harsh, but that is what we had to go on. And we knew no different.

The standard measuring ground, at East Naples Middle School, the place where it happened…was the back athletic field. It was there, in the off hours before and after school, and during PE, that we learned where each boy stood.

Our standard, at East Naples Middle, to measure up against was the vertical leap. We considered a leap to be a reasonably objective measure of athletic prowess and therefore an accurate and suitable indication of 13 year old worth. Besides that, it was a tradition handed down to us. My older brother had jumped, and every other kid’s older brother had jumped too, it was the official East Naples Middle School way of proving yourself.

At our measuring ground, to be fair, the leap was measured against a baseball backstop, which was a chain link fence that stood about fourteen and half feet tall. Each boy took his turn jumping straight up against the fence, jamming a tennis ball into the chain links as far up as he could reach.

It was, as I said, an objective measure, the highest tennis ball stuck in the fence represented the highest ranking boy…the lowest ball…the lowest ranking boy. And so it went.

In my three years of middle school I was never the top boy. I was usually fourth or fifth, a respectable place. Not the top, but thank the Lord, nowhere near the bottom.
After two years of constant measurement, I began to know from experience, that my tennis ball would hang in the fence somewhere just below William’s, John’s, and Robert’s…but somewhere just above Frank’s, Jack’s, and Danny’s. And thankfully… well above the second and third tier of boys, whose names I cannot even remember…the boys we didn’t notice much.

Now I’m not saying fourth or fifth place is wonderful, but it was bearable. I got picked early for teams, I was in the right crowd, and I was able to feel pretty good about myself. We all did…at least all of us who measured up well against the standard.

I’m sure there was an analogous feminine standard at East Naples Middle School too, but I am not aware of it’s details. I know there had to be one though, as we boys were somehow privy to their results…to who was in and who was out on their side of the gender gap.

As I said 6th and 7th grade went along well, with a comfortable predictability. John, Will, Robert, and I were usually on top, and some others were not far behind. We knew our places and we were comfortable. But in 8th grade something happened. Something that turned the whole system upside down and left us flailing in a sea of uncharted ambiguity. Something that upset the standard, blew the measurements and threatened to unhinge our entire social hierarchy. That something was Emanuel Davidson (Manny) …a boy who transferred into our school in the middle of our 8th grade year.

When we first saw Manny as he was getting registered and getting his tour of the school, we all knew he would measure up well to the standard. He was tall, athletically built, and an obvious contender right from the start. We figured right from the outset that his tennis ball would hang pretty high on the fence. But we had no idea that what would happen, would happen… much less what it would mean.

It was one or two days later that Manny first got to school early enough to have time to jump. John and Will and some of the others explained the rules to him and showed him once or twice with tennis balls of their own…and yes, Manny said…he understood the contest and he’d give it a go. And I think, he even understood it’s full implications. Manny wasn’t born yesterday.

So Manny tied his shoes tighter, flexed his grip on the tennis ball, warmed up his legs with a few hops, and made his leap. And I will never forget it…

He leapt so high, it was like he was suspended in mid air. He leapt so high, you could feel a breeze as he took off. He leapt so high, you wondered if he could reach all the way to heaven…or even if he’d break his neck falling back to earth. Emanuel Davidson leapt so high that his tennis ball was not suspended in the fence at all, but slam dunked over the top and bouncing slowly away on the other side. We were to say the least, amazed. He had scaled the whole mountain and we were still speechless on the ground.
Up to that moment we would have said it was impossible. We would have said it can’t be done. But he did it…and we all saw it. And that changed everything.

Our standard was shot. None of us could come close…not William, not John, not Robert, not me. And none of the other boys could either. It was unsettling, and we all had different reactions.

Some of us went nearly insane trying to match Manny’s leap. Some jumped day and night, but none of them got close. Others insisted he’d cheated, that he’d gotten a leg up on the base of the fence, and that it wasn’t a valid measure. Still others just gave up, despondently knowing they couldn’t come close. Some never even jumped again.

I, being bent philosophically, even from an early age pondered as I ponder to this day the implications of the Emanuel Davidson event.

Emanuel Davidson…Jesus, the holy child of God entered this world to the surprise of all. Many thought they understood the standards by which the world was run. Many thought they knew their place in it. Some tried to make themselves out to be better than others, based on those standards. Some were subjected to abuse for falling short of those standards.

Jesus jumped onto the scene and set a whole new standard, a standard that was beyond difficult, beyond improbable…a standard that was impossible to match… a standard head and shoulders above all others. In the fifth chapter of Matthew’s Gospel Jesus set the standard that all human beings including you and me:

  • should be poor in spirit, so that ours will be the kingdom
  • should be mournful, looking for holy comfort from the holy comforter
  • should be meek in order to inherit God’s own power
  • should be hungry and thirsty for righteousness, not greedy with self-interest
  • should be pure in heart, even when no one is looking
  • should be peacemakers, willing, even joyous, to be persecuted enduring for an ultimate reward.

And Jesus didn’t just say it, he did it; all the way to the cross.

Jesus slammed dunked the tennis ball over the fence and neither you nor I are ever even going to come close.

And our reaction has been the same as on our East Naples school-yard.

Some have worked themselves to death trying to match up to the Lord, but they’ve failed. Others have claimed that he cheated, that it wasn’t real, that there was some other explanation, but we know better—we’ve witnessed our Lord and we cannot deny what he has done. Still others have given up—and I pray that you haven’t and that I haven’t, because that’s not what Jesus had in mind.

Because when Jesus set this new standard he wasn’t trying to rub our noses in just how far we fall short…he was pointing out instead how far He, the God made flesh, Immanuel…was willing to come down to get us.

In fact, Jesus wants us to keep coming to the fence, but now the contest has new rules. The highest tennis ball on the fence is no better than the lowest, but instead should be the servant of all.

Pride is eliminated. The social order is destroyed. Whoever you think you are, or whoever you wish you were—is no longer important. Who you actually are, is all that counts.

And no matter who you are …the most important thing for you to know is that Jesus has gone over the fence for you.

So it seems only sensible to me that we stop trying to climb over others to get to the top; because that game is over. Instead the thing to do is to sit down on the mount this morning, at Jesus’ feet, and listen to the new rules so we too can play the new game.